Smothering Tithe is one of the most iconic white Commander staples ever printed, generating Treasure tokens whenever opponents draw cards without paying a tax. Its explosive mana generation makes it a near-auto-include in virtually every white EDH deck. The card has seen multiple reprints but the original Ravnica Allegiance printing remains the most sought-after version.
The Card Official's ruling
HOLD — Smothering Tithe has broad Commander demand but frequent reprints (including Treasure Chest and Secret Lair) create consistent price pressure. PSA 9 copies are stable but unlikely to spike significantly unless reprint supply dries up. A Commander staple that generates absurd amounts of mana in multiplayer games. Single printing until recent reprints kept the price elevated for years. Still actively played in virtually every white Commander deck. Strong hold — demand is permanent.
Price snapshot · PSA 10
PSA 10?The currently selected grade. Switch grades above to compare any two grades against each other.
$85
?The grade you want to compare against. Defaults to the lowest available grade — change it to see how any two grades compare.
$53
Tracked Grade Multiple?How many times more the selected grade sells vs the compare grade. A high multiple means grading could be very profitable.
1.6x
Price spread?The percentage difference between the low and high price estimate. A tight spread means consistent pricing; a wide spread means more volatility.
60%
Grades tracked?How many different grades we have price data for on this card — raw, PSA, BGS and others. More grades means a fuller picture of market value.
11
Last priced?When our AI last updated the price estimate for this card. Prices are refreshed weekly.
